Individuals search for private criminal defense attorneys for various reasons. Some may not meet the income eligibility requirements for a public defender. Others may prefer to choose their own attorney rather than being assigned one. Some individuals facing serious charges may want an attorney with specific experience in their type of case or familiarity with particular courts in Middlesex County.
Regardless of the reason, researching potential attorneys is an important step in the process. The law firms listed below represent a sampling of private criminal defense options in Middlesex County.
Criminal Defense Firms Serving Middlesex County

- The Law Offices of Jonathan F. Marshall
The Law Offices of Jonathan F. Marshall is a criminal defense firm with multiple offices throughout Middlesex County, including locations in New Brunswick, Edison, Woodbridge, Piscataway, and East Brunswick. The law firm focuses exclusively on criminal defense and DWI cases, representing clients in both municipal courts and Superior Court. Their main office is located directly across from the Middlesex County Courthouse in New Brunswick, providing convenient access for clients with Superior Court matters. The firm's team includes former municipal prosecutors from several Middlesex County towns, including a former Director of the Drugs Task Force and Gangs Task Force at the Middlesex County Prosecutor's Office. Free consultations are available 24/7 by phone.
What Sets Them Apart:
- Over 200 years of combined criminal defense experience across 15+ attorneys
- Former prosecutors from Edison, Woodbridge, New Brunswick, Piscataway, North Brunswick, Metuchen, South Brunswick, and Milltown
- Five office locations throughout Middlesex County
-
Certified Criminal Trial Attorneys and attorneys certified on the Alcotest breathalyzer
- Brody and Brody, Attorneys at Law
Brody and Brody is a criminal defense firm serving clients in Middlesex County and throughout Central New Jersey. The firm handles a variety of criminal matters including drug offenses, assault charges, and theft crimes. They represent clients in both municipal court and Superior Court proceedings.
Strong Points:
- Criminal defense focused practice
- Serves Central New Jersey including Middlesex County
- Handles municipal and Superior Court matters

- The Law Offices of Anthony N. Palumbo
Anthony N. Palumbo operates a criminal defense practice representing clients in Middlesex County. The firm handles cases ranging from disorderly persons offenses to serious indictable crimes. The practice provides representation in local municipal courts as well as the Middlesex County Superior Court.
Strong Points:
- Experience with range of criminal charges
- Represents clients in Middlesex County courts
- Handles both minor and serious offenses
- Lustberg Law Offices, LLC
Lustberg Law Offices handles criminal defense matters for clients in New Jersey, including those in Middlesex County. The firm takes on cases involving various criminal charges and provides representation throughout the court process from arraignment through trial.
Strong Points:
- Criminal defense representation in New Jersey
- Handles various offense types
-
Provides representation through all stages of proceedings

- The Law Office of David M. Roth
David M. Roth operates a criminal defense practice serving Middlesex County residents. The firm handles matters including drug possession, assault, domestic violence, and other criminal charges. Representation is provided in both municipal courts throughout the county and in Superior Court.
Strong Points:
- Serves Middlesex County clients
- Handles drug, assault, and domestic violence cases
-
Municipal and Superior Court representation
- Graves Andrews, LLC
Graves Andrews is a law firm providing criminal defense services in Central New Jersey. The firm represents clients facing criminal charges in Middlesex County courts and handles a range of matters from traffic offenses to more serious criminal allegations.
Strong Points:
- Central New Jersey criminal defense practice
- Range of case types handled
-
Serves Middlesex County courts
- The Law Offices of Matthew V. Russo
Matthew V. Russo operates a practice handling criminal defense matters for clients in Middlesex County. The firm represents individuals charged with various offenses and provides counsel throughout the court process.
Strong Points:
- Criminal defense focused representation
- Middlesex County practice
-
Handles various criminal matters
- Keith Oliver Criminal Law
Keith Oliver Criminal Law provides defense representation for clients facing criminal charges in New Jersey. The firm handles matters in Middlesex County courts and represents clients charged with offenses ranging from disorderly persons matters to indictable crimes.
Strong Points:
- Criminal defense practice in New Jersey
- Handles disorderly persons and indictable offenses
-
Serves Middlesex County clients
- The Law Office of Benjamin Friedman
Benjamin Friedman operates a criminal defense practice representing individuals in Middlesex County and surrounding areas. The firm handles a variety of criminal charges and provides representation in municipal courts and Superior Court.
Strong Points:
- Criminal defense representation
- Serves Middlesex County and surrounding areas
- Municipal and Superior Court experience

- Sammarro & Zalarick, P.A.
Sammarro & Zalarick handles criminal defense matters for clients in Central New Jersey, including Middlesex County. The firm represents individuals facing various criminal charges and provides counsel through all stages of the legal process.
Strong Points:
- Central New Jersey criminal defense firm
- Handles variety of criminal charges
What to Consider When Evaluating Criminal Defense Attorneys
Before reviewing specific firms, it may be helpful to consider what factors matter most when selecting a criminal defense attorney:
- Experience with Relevant Charges: Criminal law covers a broad range of offenses. Some attorneys may have particular experience with drug crimes, while others may focus on DWI defense, assault charges, or domestic violence matters.
- Familiarity with Local Courts: Middlesex County has numerous municipal courts as well as the Superior Court in New Brunswick. Attorneys who regularly appear in these venues may have valuable familiarity with local procedures.
- Former Prosecution Experience: Some criminal defense attorneys previously worked as prosecutors, which may provide insight into how the state builds cases.
- Availability and Communication: An attorney who is accessible and communicates clearly may help reduce anxiety throughout the process.
Conclusion
Choosing a criminal defense attorney depends on individual circumstances and the nature of the charges. For those seeking experienced representation in Middlesex County, The Law Offices of Jonathan F. Marshall offers over 200 years of combined experience, former prosecutors on staff, and free consultations available 24/7 to discuss legal options.